The Other Roe is a short documentary about the little-known Supreme Court case, Doe v. Bolton, decided on the same day as the better-known Roe v. Wade in 1973. While the latter became one of the most famous cases in America, the former quietly helped define the legal framework that granted women the ability to seek abortion. Through the perspective of civil rights attorney Margie Pitts Hames, the film seeks to bring this vital case back into the public eye.

The premise itself is a fascinating one, delving into the forgotten companion to the much better-known contemporary Roe v. Wade. The film is put together with clips, newspaper headlines, and talking heads in the form of Pitts Hames's friends, family, and contemporaries. Although short, the story within is one that addresses the fight for the right to access abortion, which, alongside Roe, shaped the reproductive rights of American women for over 50 years before both decisions were effectively overturned. The film itself is to the point, not wanting to dwell too much on the details, but instead focusing on reliving the moments when the court decision was handed down, granting women rights that had been previously out of reach. This is the heart of The Other Roe: its stylistic simplicity lets the narrative take the focus.

As much as I applaud the story told, the film's narrative seems understandable only to those familiar with Roe, the Georgia legal system, and American politics. I can attribute this to the film's limited runtime, under 20 minutes, which does not allow enough time to provide the context needed to fully understand the story, especially for those unfamiliar with the backgrounds of both the Doe and Roe cases. The film presents us with more of a brief overview of this moment in history without taking the time to explain and expand on their importance.

The Other Roe is a commendable effort to put the spotlight on the oft-forgotten yet desperately important legal case. Its message is timely, as the arguments first made more than 50 years ago continue to be echoed today.

About the writer

Jill Duncan

Jill Duncan is a culture writer and critic from Toronto with a background in live performance and entertainment. Reach her at jill@leagueoffilmmakers.com