Even if you're a beginner writer, you've probably heard of the terms "plotting" and "pantsing." They refer to two different writing techniques; the former refers to planning major details of your story before getting to your first draft, while the latter refers to sitting down to write without any sort of larger plan for the story in mind.

Both methods have their benefits. Plotting means that you will always know where your story is going, whereas pantsing allows you to find your way in your story based on creative instinct alone. Pantsing is aptly named after the phrase "writing by the seat of your pants."

They also both have their drawbacks. Plotters often find themselves "losing the plot", if you will. They spend too much time over-planning, often never getting to writing the story. Pantsers, on the other hand, might allow their instincts to get themselves lost. Without a metaphorical map to guide their story, they may end up backtracking, or having to restart their writing journey altogether.

So then, which method is better?

black Fayorit typewriter with printer paper
Photo by Florian Klauer / Unsplash

It's all a matter of preference.

I mostly consider myself a plotter. I tend to open my notebook and put all my plot points on a diagram. I can be pretty meticulous when it comes to my notes. I find myself starting new pages for brainstorms, family trees, character traits and relationships, and so much more.

Plotting is also the prefered method by many screenwriters. Both Save the Cat and Story recommend that writers have much of their story planned out before they get to typing their first draft.

That said, I also let my creative instincts take the lead when needed. Sometimes they chart a better path than my "map" did.

maps lying on the floor
Photo by Andrew Neel / Unsplash

Many of my peers are pantsers. They find it easier to have a general idea of what their story is and take it from there. Some of them find it easier to write non-chronologically, starting with whatever scene first forms in their mind. They find it easier to foreshadow when they know for sure what's coming.

I, on the other hand, struggle to write things out of order. I like knowing exactly what's already happened to my characters because I feel like every single detail of the past affects how a person moves forward. I find foreshadowing easier when I know I can add those important details to what's already been written.

People who tell you that there's only one way to write a story are liars. Writers with different approaches aren't more or less skilled; we all just have different techniques we prefer.

round white compass
Photo by Jordan Madrid / Unsplash

Plotting and pantsing, much like a map and compass, respectively, are just tools that a writer uses to tell their story. No one would argue that a person can only choose between a map and a compass. They're meant to be used together to find your way.

Raquel Estes
About the writer

Raquel Estes

Hi! I'm Raquel and I'm currently working towards a bachelor’s degree in film with a minor in journalism at the University of Kansas. I’ve always been interested in film as a storytelling format and enjoy getting a bit personal in my writing.